Facebook exec warns company not to be anti
A high-ranking Facebook executive and longtime Mark Zuckerberg confidant penned a long Lord of the Rings-referencing memo warning the company not to take action that would reflect a bias against President Donald Trump.
Before the New Year, Andrew Bosworth, Facebook's Vice President of augmented and virtual reality, posteda rambling 2,500 word screed to his internal Facebook page. The post offers up his thoughts on 2020 and the coming presidential election.
The New York Timesoriginally obtainedthe private memo, but Bosworth has since also made it publicly availableon his Facebook profile.
Tweet may have been deleted
The gist of Bosworth’s post is basically that Facebook absolutely had a role in electing Trump, but not for the reasons most people think.
“He didn’t get elected because of Russia or misinformation or Cambridge Analytica,” writes Bosworth. “He got elected because he ran the single best digital ad campaign I’ve ever seen from any advertiser.”
According to Bosworth, it wasn’t Russian disinformation campaigns, which he does point out as being a legitimate problem, that got Trump elected. He even discounts the spread of misinformation on the platform, which Bosworth claims is primarily economically motivated, and Cambridge Analytica’srole. It was the president’s use of Facebook’s advertising platform, spearheaded by campaign manager Brad Parscale, that helped lead to Trump’s electoral victory.
“They just used the tools we had to show the right creative to each person,” says Bosworth. “The use of custom audiences, video, ecommerce, and fresh creative remains the high water mark of digital ad campaigns in my opinion.”
Bosworth says, as a self-described liberal, he often finds himself “desperately wanting to pull any lever at my disposal to avoid the same result.” However, a scene from Lord of the Ringsapparently keeps the Facebook executive from doing so.
“Specifically when Frodo offers the ring to Galadrial (sic) and she imagines using the power righteously, at first, but knows it will eventually corrupt her,” writes Bosworth. “As tempting as it is to use the tools available to us to change the outcome, I am confident we must never do that or we will become that which we fear.”
It’s an odd take from a Facebook executive. On top of that, the Timesfelt it needed to point out that Bosworth misspelled Galadriel’s name. But the weirdness doesn’t end there.
In one section of the post, for example, Bosworth also hits back on the comparison that Facebook is like a drug addiction by saying it’s more like sugar.
“If I want to eat sugar and die an early death that is a valid position,” he writes. “My grandfather took such a stance towards bacon and I admired him for it. And social media is likely much less fatal than bacon.”
Well, okay. But, back to Bosworth’s Trump take.
It’s unclear if there is some sort of internal debate within Facebook to tip the scales against Trump that Bosworth is speaking to beyond his own internal conflict. The public criticisms aimed at the social network never implore the company to treat the president unfairly. The critiques always demand that the Facebook create just, site-wide policies which every user, including Trump, must abide by.
Take the recent criticisms of Facebook’s political ad policies. According to this policy, politicians can lie in their ads, and Facebook will run them, fact-check free, across the platform. The average Facebook user is not allowed to do this. Critics have not asked Facebook to change this policy just for Trump. They’ve demanded a disinformation-free policy on the social network that applies to every user, including politicians across the ideological spectrum.
In Bosworth’s Facebook post responding to the Timespublication of the memo, the Facebook executive says he was just “inviting internal discussion” and that his colleagues challenged him with their own takes in the comments to the internal posting.
While Bosworth use to head Facebook's advertising team, he notes that he does not work with the teams dealing with misinformation or civic integrity at the company.
Mashable reached out to Facebook for a statement but a company spokesperson just referred us back to Bosworth's latest post. The company says it will be offering no additional comment.
Interestingly, this isn’t the first time a private post from Bosworth was leaked. In 2018, Buzzfeed publishedan internal memo which he posted in 2016. That posting, which defended the platform's data collection even as it admitted people could die "in a terrorist attack coordinated on our tools," was even weirder.
The Facebook executive argued then that Facebook’s purpose was to connect people and because of that the company must continue to grow, even if people get killed as a result. Bosworth distancedhimself from that post by also claiming he just said what he did to create a discussion.
Whether Bosworth's most recent musing was intended to just fuel discussion or not, the framing of his memo is certainly noteworthy. Do other executives at the social media giant really think its critics are clamoring for the company to role out policy that just takes down a particular politician? If so, Facebook has frankly lost the plot.
Mashable has reached out to Facebook for a statement on Bosworth's memo and will update this post when we hear back.
-
When will Trump and Harris debate? The presidential campaigns snipe over ABC News’ rules.Amazon Prime Shipping: A Cost AnalysisBrexit vote: U.K. lawmakers vote to delay exit from European Union.Center for North Korean refugees opens in UKCheap heatApple will replace some MacBook Pro batteries for freePairing CPUs and GPUs: PC Upgrades and BottleneckingWe can’t actually keep Syria’s oil, but Republicans want Trump to think we can.雅安市第四人民医院:工娱治疗让患者康复之路充满希望Covid vaccine: Why it's wise to wait two weeks after your shot
下一篇:Best smartphone deal: Google Pixel 8a on sale for $449 at Amazon
- ·采购商+48,英德红茶在泉城济南蹭蹭涨粉
- ·9 best Wordle clones for fans and gamers
- ·FreeSync on Nvidia GPUs Workaround: Impractical, But It Works
- ·What just happened between Will Smith and Chris Rock at the Oscars?
- ·Tesla Robotaxis aren't coming in August, it seems
- ·What just happened between Will Smith and Chris Rock at the Oscars?
- ·Ten Haag insists Ronaldo is staying, wants more attackers
- ·Gallucci: 'Lots of questions' over North Korea's denuclearization
- ·24 Museums Dedicated to Black History
- ·How to Merge and Remove Duplicate Contacts in Android
- ·Champions League draw was Murphy's Law: Nagelsmann
- ·How to Remotely Sign Out of Gmail on Multiple Devices
- ·18 Places for Epic Outdoor Adventure Across Colorado
- ·标签不“规矩” 被罚5000元
- ·Reto wins in Canada for first LPGA title
- ·Why millions of genetically engineered mosquitoes will be released in the U.S.
- ·提前谋划部署准备秋季开学
- ·South Koreans give Kim Jong
- ·预制菜如何出海?产业生态数字化是中国美食走向国际的新航道
- ·North Korea syncs clocks with South as part of peace effort
- ·Google Gemini now allows AI
- ·Turkey, Trump, breech babies, Ohio in 2020, Futurama.
- ·Which Democrats should drop out now?
- ·Verstappen looks for home comforts at Spa
- ·广州市白云区供销联社携手6所院校15支队伍,加力提速推进“百千万工程”
- ·Elon Musk wants to turn Tesla Roadster into a hover car
- ·Pressure boost squeezes out more hydrogen from artificial leaves
- ·Android Performance Tips and Tweaks
- ·Google Chrome on iOS will soon let you make Incognito tabs a lot more private
- ·Jane Campion becomes third woman to win Oscar for Best Director
- ·SCOTUS: The courts implementing Project 2025, without Trump.
- ·师生相逢在“云端”上的课堂
- ·'Turning Red's portrayal of periods is a turning point for coming
- ·Turkey, Trump, breech babies, Ohio in 2020, Futurama.
- ·If aliens harnessed solar power, could we detect them? NASA investigated.
- ·就在明晚!来郁南无核黄皮之夜星空音乐会和“热乐团”一起燥起来!