PDF fail reveals Facebook considered selling access to data
It turns out Facebook did at one point consider selling its users' data.
We now know this not because Facebook executives had a sudden urge for transparency, but because of a bungled PDF that wasn't properly redacted.
SEE ALSO:Mark Zuckerberg believes Facebook is at 'war,' report saysThat error, which was reported by ArsTechnica, resulted in a number of email exchanges among Facebook employees being unintentionally made public. The court documents, which stem from a 2015 lawsuit against Facebook by a developer called Six4Three, are currently at the center of an inquiry by UK government officials into Facebook's data privacy practices.
The newly discovered and not-actually-redacted portions reveal that the social network did toy with the idea of giving big corporations deeper access to Facebook's data if they spent large sums of money on advertising.
Ultimately, Facebook didn't formally pursue these types of arrangements. In a statement provided to Mashable, the company's director of developer platforms and programs, Konstantinos Papamiltiadis, called the emails "misleading" and noted that Facebook has never charged developers for access to its platform.
That these emails were made public in the first place, though, is yet another embarrassing example of what can go wrong when PDF editing software isn't used properly.
ArsTechnica reporter Cyrus Farivar unearthed the supposedly redacted text when he literally copied and pasted it into a text editor. "Ars was able to access pages of blacked-out text simply by copying and pasting them into a text editor," he wrote. (The full document is available here.)
And while we don't know what exactly went wrong that made it so embarrassingly easy to decipher the text, it certainly appears that one of the law firms involved could use a refresher on how to use their PDF editing software. (The document in question originated from Six4Three. Six4Three's law firm, Birnbaum & Godkin, could not immediately be reached for comment.)
However, it turns out properly redacting text can be more complex than you might think. "In theory this stuff does happen because there's a very wrong way to do redactions," says Cathy Gellis, a cyber lawyer based in Northern California, who is not affiliated with the Six4Three case.
Tweet may have been deleted
That might be why the District Court for Northern California, where the lawsuit was originally filed, has its own guide of do's and don'ts to help attorneys properly obscure sensitive information.
The "don't" section lists several methods that should not be used, such as simply changing the color of the font to white and deleting text without stripping the associated metadata. It also notes that some editing tools may appear to "black out" text even though it's actually still visible.
Whether or not that's what happened in this case is unclear. Though it wouldn't be the first time a simple error has blown up into an embarrassing mess. Earlier this month, a prosecutor accidentally revealed that the U.S. government had filed charges against Wikileaks founder Julian Assange when a U.S. attorney copy and pasted the wrong text into a court document. It was also revealed this year that the former chairman of Donald Trump's presidential campaign, Paul Manafort, accidentally created a paper trail documenting fraud because he didn't know how to convert a Microsoft Word document into a PDF.
For lawyers, though, the Six4Three case is a reminder of what can go wrong when the tools you use don't work the way you intend. Gellis notes that it's important for attorneys to be able to understand how these mistakes happen so they can better avoid them in the future. "Part of our job is to keep lots of information secret in a lot of ways. Every lawyer has to redact documents, and you want to believe you redacted them correctly."
For what it's worth, the District Court for Northern California does recommend one redaction method it promises "will always be 100% effective," and all you need is a good pair of scissors: "cut-out (literally) all the text to be redacted and properly dispose of (shred) the clippings."
Featured Video For You
Are humans actually supposed to like coffee?
-
Apple iPod: The First 10 Years of the Ubiquitous Media PlayerSouth Korea asks UAE to correct national flag image mixFacebook employees walk out over handsFacebook employees resign over Zuckerberg's treatment of Trump postI went to an offline dating event for singles. Here's how it went.The Angle: measles, highDyson’s scrapped electric car: founder reveals what could have beenTrump’s bargaining stance ahead of his next talks with Kim JongDiscover Secret Swimming Holes and Hidden History in Crystal River, Florida我市举行2019年中小学骨干教师暑期培训
- ·Best smart home deals this week at Amazon
- ·积极改善营商环境 深化“最多跑一次”
- ·我市多家企业获评“四川省诚信示范企业”
- ·Rangnick fears for United defence at Liverpool
- ·DNC 2024 speech: Barack Obama and Michelle Obama have a superpower no other Democrat has.
- ·被执行人死亡 遗产继承人是否要担责
- ·Rangnick fears for United defence at Liverpool
- ·Netflix and Zoom is the new Netflix and chill
- ·雨城区疾控中心提示:科学补碘 防治碘缺乏病
- ·培养乡村振兴梦之队”!全国人大代表建议获答复
- ·Military reports 78 more COVID
- ·Tucker Carlson interview: Watch Fox News host tell Dutch historian to “go f
- ·应对高温 户外驿站送清凉
- ·Ranking every MCU movie based on how dramatic Loki acts
- ·首批9名“智囊”持证上岗!中国乡村文化振兴专家委员会成立
- ·预制饶味,抢“鲜”未来!鲜食材,好工夫,方成饶平预制菜
- ·Malan retires from international cricket
- ·Can UV light sanitize hotel and Airbnb rooms?
- ·NYC taps Twilio to power its massive contact
- ·Leaked Microsoft Surface Duo specs, if true, aren't all that exciting
- ·[Online Predators] Deepfake pornography haunts S. Korea
- ·Military reports 144 more COVID
- ·What to do when you can't sleep
- ·Your national parks are free during coronavirus
- ·Number Representations in Computer Hardware
- ·Amazon launches faster Fire HD 8 tablets with more storage
- ·22 Unusual Things You Can Find in the Desert
- ·Everyone's favorite goat farm is posting a soothing video every day
- ·Interview with Malwarebytes' founder, Marcin Kleczynski
- ·The Angle: Supreme Court forfeiture, Bernie Sanders, movie censorship.
- ·Tesla considers adding a new ‘stuck detection' feature to Cybertruck. Here’s why.
- ·金凤山公园二期计划今年国庆假期开放
- ·Military reports 144 more COVID
- ·我市举行2019年中小学骨干教师暑期培训
- ·科创筑梦树立远大志向 蓄势赋能培养科技人才
- ·Here’s how to create your Facebook Avatar in a few simple steps