ACLU says ICE and CBP searching electronics violates the Constitution
These days "the border" is used more as an inflammatory concept than an actual place with rules and laws. Now, the ACLU is trying to puncture that hot air with some help from the Constitution.
In preparation for a lawsuit the ACLU is bringing against the federal government, U.S. officials from Customs and Border Protection (CBP) and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) had an under-oath chat with the ACLU about how exactly they search electronic devices at the border when they don't have a warrant or "suspicion."
SEE ALSO:Amazon must let shareholders have a say in selling of controversial facial recognition techThe ACLU reports that the testimony was revealing: Agents of these agencies can and do justify searching devices like laptops and cellphones for a variety of nebulous reasons not covered by the actual, ya know, law.
"CBP and ICE are asserting near-unfettered authority to search and seize travelers’ devices at the border, for purposes far afield from the enforcement of immigration and customs laws," the ACLU wrote in a blog post.
ICE and CBP have the authority to search the belongings of people entering the country for contraband, potentially breaking immigration law, and, of course, if they have a warrant. But the ACLU says these agencies are using "the border" as an excuse to skirt the privacy and speech protections enshrined by the Constitution.
"The government cannot use the pretext of the 'border' to make an end run around the Constitution," the ACLU writes. "The border is not a lawless place."
CBP and ICE representatives said that the agencies do not comment on pending litigation. ICE directed Mashable to CBP electronics search and seizure guidelines stating that "CBP searches the electronic devices of fewer than one-hundredth of 1 percent of all arriving international travelers."
"In this digital age, border searches of electronic devices are essential to enforcing the law at the U.S. border and to protecting the American people,” John Wagner, the CBP's deputy executive assistant commissioner, office of field operations, says in the guidelines. “CBP is committed to preserving the civil rights and civil liberties of those we encounter, including the small number of travelers whose devices are searched, which is why the updated Directive includes provisions above and beyond prevailing constitutional and legal requirements."
Beyond this statement by the CBP on its website, the ACLU reported that law enforcement officers admit that they search and seize devices for a host of reasons, which the ACLU says are beyond their direct jurisdiction. To name a few, agents said they will search devices to advance general law enforcement investigations (e.g., bankruptcy), at the request of another agency, or to get information about a contact of the owner of the device.
The ACLU claims these searches violate the first and fourth amendments. The fourth amendment protects against unreasonable search and seizure. For something that contains as much personal information as an electronic device, a search would typically require a warrant.
The first amendment protects against freedom of speech and freedom of the press. The ACLU says these searches may cause people to self-censor, so searches violate the first amendment. Additionally, some of the ACLU's clients on behalf of whom it is bringing the lawsuit are journalists. Searches of these individuals' devices — for information on their sources and reporting — might cause them to stop reporting out of fear.
Given these findings, the ACLU is asking the judge in its case to skip the trial and rule on behalf of its clients — U.S. citizens who have experienced unreasonable search and seizure. It wants the judge to send a message, that if a law enforcement officer wants to search a device, they need to get a warrant like everybody else.
UPDATE: May 1, 2019, 12:28 p.m. EDT
This article was updated to include a 'no comment' from ICE, as well as more information about the CBP's stance on electronic search procedures.
Featured Video For You
2018 was the year of the youth activist
-
Where to preNice loan deal for Justin KluivertIntel report indicates that a 5G iPhone won't happen until 2020Chrissy Teigen's impression of Luigi hunting ghosts is absolutely on pointUnderstanding Relational vs. NonDisney releases first ever full line of LGBTQ Pride merchandiseWell, Prince Harry and Meghan Markle bathing suits are a thing nowUber drivers say London's new congestion charge is 'discrimination'21 Unexpected Wonders in Colorado’s Vibrant Cities and Small TownsApple rumored to release a stack of new gadgets in 2020. Here's what we know.
下一篇:Top 10 Most Significant Nvidia GPUs of All Time
- ·Ruling bloc seeks tougher sentences for deepfake sex crimes
- ·G108线汉源九襄段 单向循环管制通行
- ·Beethoven's 'Ode to Joy' is smashing the UK charts thanks to Brexit
- ·N. Korea unlikely to carry out provocations ahead of S. Korea
- ·The Techies Who Lunch
- ·Mike Pompeo's tantrum inspired a big boost in NPR donations
- ·We defy you not to sob uncontrollably at these photos of Harry and Meghan getting married
- ·诚信为本 有诉必回
- ·Europe now has a huge AI gap, for better or for worse
- ·宝兴联社利用节假日契机 宣传金融知识
- ·You simply must see these celebrities lose themselves during Eminem's Oscars performance
- ·Instagram might soon let you send multiple photos and videos in DMs
- ·Webb telescope just snapped image of huge black hole gobbling material
- ·创新社保服务领域 打造贴心社保服务
- ·Rowden fears self
- ·Instagram is the most used platform for grooming crimes, report finds
- ·Essential Apps to Install on your Windows PC or Mac
- ·Lime scooter bug sees riders injured after 'sudden excessive braking'
- ·Watch out for this extremely fake, weirdly racist viral post about coronavirus
- ·Rick Santorum: Parkland students should be learning CPR instead of marching.
- ·Best Labor Day mattress deals in 2024
- ·全面实现一站式服务、一次性告知
- ·Instagram is the most used platform for grooming crimes, report finds
- ·North Korea rejects COVID
- ·Venture Missionaries
- ·Energizer's 18,000mAh battery phone is as thick as 3 normal phones
- ·Best Labor Day mattress deals in 2024
- ·市人民医院开展女职工登山健身活动
- ·Microsoft bolsters cloud security with more AI threat detection
- ·Tesla's 'Full Self
- ·Apple iPod: The First 10 Years of the Ubiquitous Media Player
- ·Mike Pompeo's tantrum inspired a big boost in NPR donations
- ·全面实现一站式服务、一次性告知
- ·Amazon will open new grocery stores separate from Whole Foods, report says
- ·Klarna CEO reveals plan to reduce workforce by 50% and replace it with AI
- ·1TB microSD cards are here and I irrationally want one