In the Russia
The Russian government is trying to control the narrative around its invasion of Ukraine. One place its messages can either take hold without fact-checking, or get thoroughly debunked and rebutted, is on messaging apps like Telegram and Meta-owned WhatsApp.
Social media companies like Twitter and Meta have been putting extra measures in place to counter President Putin's propaganda machine. Russia relies on state-affiliated agencies like RT, Sputnik, TASS, and others, to share the Russian government's version of events. Recently, Twitter rolled out warning labels with tweets sharing links from these websites making their Russian state-affiliation known. Meta has blocked the links entirely in Europe.
But these public channels are just one way that information spreads. In 2021, a New York University study found that Donald Trump tweets flagged by Twitter proliferated on other social networks.
"Tweets spread on other platforms despite having labels on them," Joshua Tucker, an NYU professor who is an expert in both Russian studies and social media and disinformation, said. Public-facing channels where it's possible to moderate content aren't, he said, "the only place people are going to be spreading information."
According to Statista, the most popular messaging app in Russia is WhatsApp. But Tucker, as well as Russian historian Ian Garner, who has been analyzing the spread of propaganda on Russian social media, say Telegram has been the dominant messaging platform amid the conflict. Telegram is a hybrid platform that has private one-on-one and group chats (that can have as many as 200,000 members), as well as "channels" where the channel owner can broadcast, or that may function as more of a forum.
Signal and WhatsApp are end-to-end encrypted by default, meaning not even the platforms themselves can see what users are sending to each other. On Telegram, however, only chats that users proactively enable as "secret" carry end-to-end encryption. This is only available for one-to-one chats. Otherwise, Telegram uses a different type of encryption that the founder of Signal and others have called out for being less secure.
Tweet may have been deleted
Encryption is great for privacy. But in the past, these platforms have enabled the spread of misinformation. And because platforms are not able to moderate content (though WhatsApp has put in place a reporting mechanism), countering fake news has required platform functionality changes and dedicated campaigns.
WhatsApp has rolled out one of these campaigns to counter propaganda or help with general confusion that may be spreading on its platform. The head of WhatsApp, Will Cathcart, tweeted Tuesday that Ukraine Emergency Services had launched a helpline meant to provide people with quality information about the situation.
Tweet may have been deleted
While these campaigns are important, it's still hard to even understand — let alone combat — misinformation on encrypted messaging apps.
"It's really difficult to know what's going on on those platforms," Tucker said.
In the past, misinformation has spread on WhatsApp through one-to-one messages and groups (that have a maximum size of 256 members). WhatsApp's "forwarding" functionality and large groups enabled fake news to spread quickly, untethered from an original source. WhatsApp limited the function after it led to real-world consequences in India and Brazil.
But passing the harmful content didn't happen by accident. Kiran Garimella, who studied WhatsApp's role in spreading the misinformation in India that led to mob violence, said that sewing fake news typically requires "bad actors" to build up information networks. While Tucker noted that the West's understanding of Russia prior to the conflict was that it had a "sophisticated propaganda machine," it's not actually known whether Russia has developed these sort of networks on WhatsApp.
Even if that is the case, experts are finding that messaging apps which offer encryption have been serving an incredibly important purpose: Amplifying counter-propaganda, the voices of Russian protesters, and the experiences of Ukrainians.
"Because the government can't install its own moderators, and direct control over censorship of both platforms, we're finding that it's really free space for Russians to be able to discuss anything they'd like about the war," Garner said. "The fact that these discussions are taking place, and taking place quite openly and yet anonymously for individual users, means the government has a problem on its hands."
Garner points to several Russian-language Telegram channels with over a million subscribers that are criticizing the government's assurances that everything is fine in Russia. The Russian government does run Telegram channels for its state-affiliated media, like Sputnik. But of those channels' hundreds of thousands of followers, it's unclear how many are real people, and how many are bots. In the past, Tucker noted, Russia has heavily relied on bots to amplify its messages and increase the apparent popularity of its posts.
The fact that it's harder to monitor and moderate activity on these platforms doesn't mean they should be ignored. In fact, understanding the flow of information is only going to become more crucial as the information war that accompanies the on-the-ground war ramps up.
"We're into the realm where I think the disinformation is going to be part and parcel with the military strategy," Tucker said. Misinformation will be able to spread at lightning speed, but so, too, will the people on messaging platforms who can fight against it.
"It's going to cut both ways," Tucker said.
UPDATE: Mar. 4, 2022, 1:55 p.m. EST This article was updated to clarify the differences in encryption levels between Telegram and other messaging apps.
-
Alcaraz, Sinner survive US Open wobbles银行加速清理“睡眠卡”持卡人还须留意自身账户安全The creators of the world's most hated font still love itTsitsipas calls for coaching to be allowed during matchesBy a technicality, August's full moon is blue. Here's why.PM's Office sends inspection team to Samsung hospital over MERSKid won't take no for an answer: Builds a Nintendo Switch out of cardboardThe long goodbye: Barca say adios to MessiNetanyahu’s InfernoWikiLeaks dump shows how CIA compromised iPhones and Macs
下一篇:Echo Dot (5th gen) deal — get it for $29.99 at Amazon
- ·Google Search tries new tactics for limiting explicit deepfakes
- ·Football should be sold with health warning, says dementia expert
- ·MERS spreads to more facilities
- ·Tokyo Games offer transfer hopefuls limelight to show skills
- ·The Analog Embrace: How Some Experiences Are Surviving the Digital Age
- ·Ruling party to push for vote on PM nominee
- ·Grealish's City debut spoiled as Leicester win Community Shield
- ·Park says considerable progress made with Japan on sex slaves
- ·17 Spectacular Outdoor Staircases
- ·Tired Olympian Nishikori wins ATP Washington opener
- ·Experts say MERS not lethal to healthy people
- ·Fire breaks out at hotel in Pyongyang: reports
- ·Pope says England are not 'one
- ·Seoul mayor lambasts Samsung Medical Center
- ·Florida man discovers huge snake has been living in his attic for years
- ·银行加速清理“睡眠卡”持卡人还须留意自身账户安全
- ·How much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?
- ·Seoul's arms exports to Poland help NATO tackle capabilities gap amid Ukraine war: U.S. envoy
- ·Dehydration is on trend, according to Kanye West's latest fashion show
- ·'There's a place at Google for you,' Google CEO tells girls at coding competition
- ·Republicans on abortion
- ·Chinese ship might have to pay $120 million in Great Barrier Reef clean
- ·Chelsea agree club record deal to re
- ·PSG make winning start as Messi arrival looms
- ·CPUs Don't Matter For 4K Gaming... Wrong!
- ·Ruling party unilaterally adopts confirmation report on new PM
- ·World's first 18650
- ·[Newsmaker] Seoul mayor capitalizes on MERS response
- ·N. Korean human rights bill unlikely to pass Congress this year again
- ·Sinclair rewarded with Olympic gold
- ·13 Unbelievable Underwater Wonders in Florida
- ·S. Korea, Japan to hold talks over UNESCO world heritage next week
- ·Seoul mayor lambasts Samsung Medical Center
- ·In other celebrity breakup news, Amber Heard and Elon Musk have reportedly broken up
- ·The local version of Project 2025 is already causing devastation.
- ·Maxine Waters tweets Trump impeachment joke, gets best response