Seventh Circuit refuses to stay Wisconsin voting rights decision.
On Monday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7thCircuit refused to block a lower court decision invalidating large chunks of Wisconsin’s Republican-sponsored voting restrictions. The ruling effectively ensures that Wisconsin’s most burdensome new voting laws will not be in effect during the 2016 election, unless the Supreme Court intervenes—an extremely remote possibility. With this denial, the 7thCircuit joins a growing list of federal courts that are willing to question the impact of voting restrictions on minorities’ constitutionally protected right to vote.
The 7thCircuit’s refusal to stay the lower court’s ruling is especially remarkable in light of that decision’s broad holding. In his ruling, U.S. District Judge James D. Peterson barred Wisconsin from enforcing a significant rollback on early voting—especially on days favored by black voters—along with more stringent components of the voter ID provision. Peterson found that these measures placed an undue burden on citizens’ right to vote and violated the First, 14th, and 15thamendments, as well as the Voting Rights Act. He also found that a Wisconsin law that slashed hours for in-person absentee voting intentionally discriminated on the basis of race, a serious charge against the state Legislature. In one startling passage, Peterson slammed Republican legislators for their “preoccupation with mostly phantom election fraud,” an obsession that “leads to real incidents of disenfranchisement, which undermine rather than enhance confidence in elections, particularly in minority communities.”
Earlier this month, the same panel of judges that refused to stay Peterson’s ruling agreed to stay a different judge’s decision softening other elements of Wisconsin’s voter ID requirements. The order would have allowed voters unduly burdened by the law to sign an affidavit instead of presenting ID. In its ruling, the 7thCircuit found that the district court hadn’t differentiated between individuals for whom the ID requirement presents a “substantial obstacle to voting” and those who could easily get an ID but don’t want to “make the effort.”
As election law expert Rick Hasen notes, the same panel’s willingness to let Peterson’s ruling stand is rather revealing. Even for these conservative-leaning judges, it seems, Wisconsin’s race-based early voting cuts go beyond the pale. And thanks to their willingness to peer beyond the Legislature’s laughably pretextual justifications for disenfranchisement, thousands more Wisconsin voters will be able to cast their ballots this November.
Tweet Share Share Comment-
21 Unexpected Wonders in Colorado’s Vibrant Cities and Small TownsThe Fairphone 3 is a green, laborProsecutors all set to grill ParkF1 stars unwind on month9 Festive Holiday Treats and Where to Find ThemInsect scientists want your help renaming bugs with racist namesRussia takes swipe at US missile defense in South KoreaThe young woman teaching kids about space onlineThe Future of Tech: The Desktop PC专家开讲为高三学生减压
下一篇:Webb telescope discovers 6 rogue worlds. They didn't form the way you'd expect.
- ·10 Places to Get to Know Paul Bunyan
- ·Insect scientists want your help renaming bugs with racist names
- ·Noah Syndergaard just revealed some tantalizing hints about his 'Game of Thrones' cameo
- ·F1 stars unwind on month
- ·Best smart home deal: The Amazon Smart Thermostat is just $63.99
- ·El Salvador wants to be the first nation to treat bitcoin like cash
- ·26米长卷写意水墨上里
- ·Questions rise over North Korea’s announcement of 'successful' missile test
- ·Upgrade Your Monitor, Not Your GPU
- ·That viral Selkie puff dress only works for the Instagram fantasy world
- ·Microsoft HoloLens delivers first ever augmented reality Easter Egg hunt
- ·Your ability to make random choices may peak at age 25
- ·How much for Oasis tickets? Fans joke about splurging on reunion shows
- ·How to add an admin to a Facebook page
- ·[From the Scene] Final preparations underway to lift sunken Sewol ferry
- ·昨日跌破2800点 本周市场能够绝地反击?
- ·New Grok response directs users to Vote.gov for election questions
- ·Prosecutors all set to grill Park
- ·市地税局税法宣传进企业
- ·Threesomes are seemingly more popular than ever in 2021
- ·Is Mercury retrograde messing with you? Think again.
- ·Man City back at Premier League summit
- ·Prosecutors all set to grill Park
- ·How to add an admin to a Facebook page
- ·Venture Missionaries
- ·26米长卷写意水墨上里
- ·Venture Missionaries
- ·Why Instagram keeps serving an ad that looks like a pile of poo
- ·Trash balloons, propaganda leaflets escalate tensions on Korean Peninsula
- ·Please don't name April the giraffe's baby Harambe
- ·Cyrix: Gone But Not Forgotten
- ·Arsenal back on top of Premier League
- ·Democratic Party opposes hasty constitutional revision
- ·Andreeva shines under Madrid lights
- ·Campbell highlights Washington Declaration amid security concerns over Putin
- ·Ding becomes China's first world chess champion