Here's the difference between Chelsea Manning's case and Edward Snowden's
With the stunning news that a bulk of Chelsea Manning's remaining sentence has been commuted by President Obama, there's an obvious question in the air about that other infamous leaker of government document troves, Edward Snowden.
Mainly: Why grant mercy to Chelsea Manning, but not Edward Snowden?
SEE ALSO:Obama commutes majority of Chelsea Manning's sentenceIt's easy to conflate the two, due in no small part to the fact that Snowden issued his own heart-felt call to Obama to commute Manning's sentence just last week.
Tweet may have been deleted
But people—many important ones—see a major rift between the two. In a statement to media today, White House press secretary Josh Earnest was crystal clear in what he saw as the "stark difference" between the two cases of Manning and Snowden:
On Chelsea Manning:
“Chelsea Manning is somebody who went through the military criminal justice process, was exposed to due process, was found guilty, was sentenced for her crimes, and she acknowledged wrongdoing,” [Earnest] said.
On Edward Snowden:
“Mr. Snowden fled into the arms of an adversary, and has sought refuge in a country that most recently made a concerted effort to undermine confidence in our democracy.”
Even more:
In Manning's case, the documents leaked related to the ongoing military operation in Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as diplomatic cables, and information about detainees in Guantanamo. Many of Manning's documents related to the war were about operations that already happened, and documents that revealed the number of civilian casualties to be higher than what the U.S. government was reporting at the time. In Snowden's case, the leaks detailed massive surveillance programs that were currently under use by U.S. intelligence agencies, including cracking encryption, collecting data-like text messages from cell phone carriers, and surveillance of other nations, including several allies.
Chelsea Manning leaked documents directly to WikiLeaks after being turned down by several newspapers, including the New York Times. Eventually, the Times, as well as The Guardianand German paper Der Spiegel, would go on to publish excerpts from the documents. Edward Snowden's documents were leaked to multiple outlets, including the Washington Postand The Guardianand, later, The New York Timesand Der Spiegel.
Government officials also noted that while Manning's leaks were information, Snowden's leaks showed, in detail, exactly how intelligence agencies went about collecting information, which could give enemies of the United States a better idea of how to avoid detection and circumvent U.S. efforts to undermine their plans.
Snowden, for his part, has expressed gratitude towards the U.S. Government in commuting Manning's sentence.
Tweet may have been deleted
Given the White House's take on the matter, Snowden's gratitude not withstanding, it certainly doesn't look like he's going to be on the receiving end of any help from the American government any time soon. For all the various ways the Obama administration and the forthcoming Trump administration seem to differ, given the last time he weighed in on it, it looks like the matter of Edward Snowden is one of the few things he and Obama can seem to agree on:
Tweet may have been deleted
Then again, given Trump's ever-evolving dynamic with Moscow, that one's potentially up in the air these days, too.
Featured Video For You
Edward Snowden says Russians probably hacked the NSA
-
PS5 Pro: There are new whispers that the release date is fast approaching 促进优质医疗资源下沉 推动医疗资源合理配置共赢增值表蓝皮书重磅发布,海尔创物联网时代管理会计新范式娴蜂俊瑙嗗儚鍔犳帹 Vidda瀛愬搧鐗屾鎷撳勾杞荤敤鎴穇涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝16 of the Most Epic Sandwiches Around the Planet小事不出村 驻村诉讼服务点助力矛盾化解平度女教师创作36米巨幅剪纸喜迎“十九大”鍖椾含涓€宸ュ湴鎸栧嚭鐭崇 鏂囦繚閮ㄩ棬锛氬皢娲句笓浜鸿浆杩恄涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝热浪来袭 科学应对防中暑鈥滈煶鈥濅负鏈変綘 鍦伴搧闊充箰鍘呬竷澶曡妭鎯呮瓕涓撳満婕斿嚭鏉ュ暒!
下一篇:17 Places That Harness the Power of the Sun
- ·“精致小春姐”顾春芳:华丽白西装、镶钻水晶拖鞋,带来新兴凉果No.1
- · 一根网线连通致富路 农业跑出云端加速度
- ·《失忆的年代》将排话剧 陶虹曹力朗读会小试牛刀
- ·闈掓槬鏃犵晱锛岀悆鍦虹浉浼 闈掑矝绉诲姩缁勭粐寮€灞曟柊鑰佸憳宸ョ鐞冨鎶楄禌
- ·Michael Cohen fights Donald Trump at the Supreme Court.
- ·闈掑矝澶у墽闄㈠皢涓婃紨鏋楀厗鍗庣幇瀹炰富涔変含鍛冲効璇濆墽銆婅€佽垗浜斿垯銆媉涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
- ·平安人寿青岛分公司:举办“新青岛 新征程 新辉煌”区部课经理大会
- ·广东不止花市旺,绿美菜市带你玩转“种菜圈”!
- ·Scientists discover where the huge dinosaur
- ·受地震影响 成雅、成贵、成昆等多条铁路线部分列车将晚点
- ·启动应急预案 做好安全教育
- ·银行百万优惠 提振消费信心
- ·共同推动雅安职工思想政治引领数智化发展工作做深做实
- ·落实“三强化”举措 推进绿色生态校园建设
- ·斯巴达勇士赛青岛站赛前体验会举行 4项障碍提前亮相
- ·救命技能全get!青岛品牌日
- ·I used the Pixel 9 Pro XL in the shower — does the screen work when wet as claimed?
- ·平安人寿青岛分公司:组织银发金融大讲堂 走进即墨区夕阳红老年公寓
- ·加强宣传 营造未成年人保护良好氛围
- ·养猪为何成了饲料企业的利润黑洞?
- ·18 Slightly Submerged Architectural Wonders
- ·斯巴达勇士赛青岛站赛前体验会举行 4项障碍提前亮相
- ·组团参观享福利!2021青岛应急救援展9月8日
- ·共赢增值表蓝皮书重磅发布,海尔创物联网时代管理会计新范式
- ·Doosan scraps controversial Robotics
- ·闈掑矝宸ヨ锛氫竴浣撳寲娓犻亾寤鸿淇冮珮璐ㄩ噺鍙戝睍
- ·Apple Intelligence is now a little easier to get outside the U.S.
- · 一根网线连通致富路 农业跑出云端加速度
- ·省第三届半岛蓝色经济区健身联动活动昨天举行
- ·崂山乡村美图亮相平遥古城
- ·阳江村K开麦,阳西3人晋级!
- ·平安人寿青岛分公司:举办“新青岛 新征程 新辉煌”区部课经理大会
- ·最会做菜的佛山,拥有最可口的年味丨广东年货大摸底佛山篇
- ·助力乡村振兴 跟进项目孵化
- ·17 Spectacular Outdoor Staircases
- ·鏃ュ鐞嗚兘鍔涙彁鍗?涓囧惃锛屽嵆澧ㄨタ閮ㄦ薄姘村鐞嗗巶鎵╁缓鍙婂崌绾у畬鎴恄涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝