What the anti–death penalty and anti
Like previous generations of anti-abortion activists in the immediate post–Roe v. Wadeworld, people seeking to end the death penalty have no prospect of winning in the Supreme Court. And much like those activists, the movement to abolish the death penalty has had to adapt its strategy.
As Sarah Kliff observed at Vox, the pro-life movement experimented with different ways of accomplishing this goal, “whether targeting abortion providers, their clinics, or the procedures a woman has to go through before terminating a pregnancy.”
And in state after state, the anti-abortion movement succeeded.
Today, death penalty abolitionists are trying to do something similar. Just as the pro-life movement has, unfortunately for women across the country, been successful in slowing or stopping them from exercising their legal rights and obtaining abortions, the gradualist, incremental strategy of death penalty abolitionists shows great promise.
Rather than mounting a frontal assault on capital punishment, in many states and localities, anti–death penalty activists are trying to ensure that even when the death penalty is legal, it will be hard, costly, or impossible to use.
One part of the strategy involves making it hard for states to get drugs for lethal injection. Another is to mount vigorous, extended court battles to save or delay the execution of particular capital defendants.
Another key, and novel, part of the effort is convincing prosecutors—seemingly unlikely allies—not to bring capital cases.
AdvertisementLast week, the movement succeeded in doing just that. On Feb. 17, 56 prosecutors from across the country issued a joint statement saying that “our country’s system of capital punishment is broken. It is time to work together toward systemic changes that will bring about the elimination of the death penalty nationwide.”
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThis statement marks a watershed moment in the struggle to end the death penalty in the United States.
Prosecutors play a key, but sometimes underappreciated, role throughout America’s criminal justice system. They have virtually unlimited discretion to decide whether to initiate or proceed with any criminal case. Then–Attorney General Robert Jackson got it right when in 1940 he said that the “prosecutor has more power over life, liberty, and reputation than any other person in America,” and that “his discretion is tremendous.”
AdvertisementWhat is true in other parts of the justice system is also true in capital cases. Prosecutors make the critical choice of whether or not to charge an offender with an offense that carries the possibility of a death sentence. And “despite the grave implications of this decision,” as Jonathan DeMay wrote in Fordham Urban Law Journal years ago, “the United States Supreme Court has never required that any procedures or guidelines be promulgated to control the process employed by prosecutors to reach this decision.”
According to the educational group Capital Punishment in Context, “the financial resources available in a jurisdiction, the views of constituents and the local political climate, and the prosecutor’s own views can affect the likelihood a defendant will face the death sentence.”
Advertisement AdvertisementSo great is this prosecutorial power that some opponents of capital punishment argue that “whether someone is sentenced to death has become more a function of the prosecutor on their case than the severity of their crime.” Even when they use this power in an arbitrary or discriminatory manner or engage in egregious misconduct, they are rarely disciplined by either the bar or the courts.
A 2016 report by Harvard Law School’s Fair Punishment Project found that just five prosecutors—Joe Freeman Britt of Robeson County, North Carolina; Robert Macy of Oklahoma County, Oklahoma; Donald Myers of the 11thJudicial District of South Carolina; Lynne Abraham of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; and Johnny Holmes of Harris County, Texas—were“responsible for more than 440 death sentences, the equivalent of 15 percent of the entire U.S. death row population today.”
Advertisement AdvertisementAfter each of those prosecutors left office, the number of death sentences in the jurisdictions they served declined significantly.
Last week’s joint statement was signed by prosecutors from metropolitan and rural counties in 26 states, 11 of which currently have the death penalty. The statement acknowledged that those who signed it “hold varied opinions surrounding the death penalty and hail from jurisdictions with different starting points on the propriety of this sentence.”
Advertisement AdvertisementYet they joined forces in endorsing a wide range of abolitionist arguments. “We have a capital punishment system,” their statement noted, “that costs taxpayers over $1 million per death sentence, runs counter to our constitutional ban against cruel and unusual punishment and guarantees of due process and equal protection, fails as an effective deterrent, and does not reduce crime.”
AdvertisementThe prosecutors also acknowledged the disparities inherent in capital punishment cases, noting:
The death penalty still targets not the worst of the worst, but rather the unluckiest of the unluckiest: people who endured sexual abuse and other unspeakable trauma as children; people with long histories of severe mental illness or traumatic brain injuries … people who committed crimes during a psychotic break they can’t even remember; people who, because of incomplete cognitive development or other intellectual disability, have never been able to fully function as adults; people with trial lawyers so derelict in their duties and obligations that they never bothered to uncover long histories of illness and trauma. This, tragically, is the profile of death row in America.
The 56 prosecutors pledged not to seek the death penalty “against individuals with cognitive impairments or otherwise diminished culpability.” They also said they would “work toward the elimination of our nation’s failed death penalty system, once and for all.”
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- America Needs to Grow Up
- The Horrible Truth About Shaken Baby Syndrome Cases
- The Degradation of Donald Trump Attorney Todd Blanche Is Already Complete
- The Trump Defense Made Hope Hicks Cry. The Prosecution Got What It Wanted.
Other prosecutors have gone further, and announced that they will no longer bring capital prosecutions under anycircumstances. In September, Utah prosecutor David Leavitt made headlines when he said his office would no longer seek the death penalty in any case. He explained that “innocent people have been executed and that the penalty of death has been carried out inconsistently and discriminatorily. What we have also learned is that the death penalty does not promote community safety. It is not an effective deterrent. It simply demonstrates our societal preference for retribution over public safety.”
AdvertisementFifty years ago this year, the United States Supreme Court brought a temporary halt to the death penalty when it ruled that it could not be squared with the Constitution’s prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment and guarantee of equal treatment under the law. That decision represented the culmination of a campaign to put litigation at the center of abolitionist strategy and the hope for a sweeping, top-down end to capital punishment. But the decision did not hold.
Today the strategy to end capital punishment is much less focused on the Supreme Court. Rather, and much like what the movement to stop abortion did until just recently, it aims one step, one jurisdiction, at a time to bring the machinery of death to a halt.
Enlisting prosecutors to join in this work is one mark of its success.
Tweet Share Share Comment-
Garmin Fenix 8 vs. Apple Watch Ultra: The Fenix wins big on battery life8 Great Gargoyles and Grotesques to Both Terrify and Amuse9 Places to Deepen Your Knowledge of the Underground RailroadThe Supreme Court has no reason to end affirmative action. They’re doing it anyway.Webb telescope just snapped image of huge black hole gobbling materialThe U.S. and Russia are both running their annual nuclear war exercises right nowInstagram and Facebook might let you go adTrump to allow imports of elephant trophies on 'case抖音超600万次传播量!广东省农事运动会乡村直播大赛火出圈Amazon NFL Black Friday deals: How to shop
下一篇:24 Museums Dedicated to Black History
- ·广州市白云区供销联社携手6所院校15支队伍,加力提速推进“百千万工程”
- ·S. Korea, US discuss NK cyber threats
- ·10 Vending Machines Offering Contact
- ·Fish Out of Water
- ·Naver, Kakao strive to combat deepfake porn spreading online
- ·Rhino experts are not expecting to save threatened species with IVF
- ·Seoul offers interactive real
- ·Rishi Sunak: What the Indian diaspora thinks of the incoming U.K. prime minister.
- ·Best Labor Day mattress deals in 2024
- ·Mysterious bowhead whales found singing over 180 different songs
- ·US urges Russia, China to hold N. Korea accountable for recent provocations
- ·[Photo News] Protest in Seoul
- ·'Hyundai Way': Auto giant's W121tr plan aims to seize mobility market lead
- ·Seoul offers interactive real
- ·N. Korean missile launches destabilize region: Pentagon
- ·Seoul issues advisory against hiring NK IT workers with disguised nationalities
- ·CeeDee Lamb secures record
- ·Humans stalked and hunted giant sloths, footprints discovery suggests
- ·S. Korea, US discuss NK cyber threats
- ·Benzema tempted by Saudi Arabia's 'huge' football project
- ·What to expect from Apple's September event: iPhone 16, Apple Watch 10, and more
- ·Seoul, Tokyo cooperation critical to dealing with NK, economic challenges: envoys
- ·North Korean leader's sister calls Yoon 'idiot,' says Seoul now 'target'
- ·China trumps US in satellite navigation technology, warns new report
- ·I used the Pixel 9 Pro XL in the shower — does the screen work when wet as claimed?
- ·Black Friday gaming console deal: Xbox Series S and Series X bundles are up to $120 off
- ·Tesla Robotaxis aren't coming in August, it seems
- ·North Korea's state TV releases photos of leader Kim, his daughter, for 2nd straight day
- ·North Korea's state TV releases photos of leader Kim, his daughter, for 2nd straight day
- ·US working to improve early warning system against N. Korean missile launches: US commander
- ·Sports minister says audits into football, badminton federations set to conclude in Sept.
- ·我市出台促进文化旅游发展激励政策
- ·Liz Truss resignation: her fall was wild, but what’s coming will be worse.
- ·攻坚克难 敢为人先 扎实推进各项涉水目标任务
- ·14 Heists, Robberies, and Other Great Capers
- ·Google Meet: Raise your hand in real life, and the new feature will detect it