IVF Alabama ruling: The GOP is panicking over this horrendous decision.
A preview of this story was featuredin the Surge, Slate’s weekly newsletter about all the most important political nonsense. Subscribe now!
To the fellas in the Republican Party: Are we having fun yet with post-Dobbsreproductive rights policy? As was not unexpected after Dobbs, a state Supreme Court (Alabama’s in this case) has determined that frozen embryos have personhood rights, prompting the state’s largest hospital to halt IVF treatments for fear of legal repercussions. This is a fully insane situation. The vast majority of everyone supports access to IVF as practiced.
But—but but but!—this is the sort of outcome you will get when you enshrine into law that personhood begins at the moment of fertilization, and that’s a litmus test for many Republican candidates. And so, over the past week, we’ve seen them tripping all over their own faces trying to discuss the decision. Here’s Nikki Haley last week in her cleanup effort, fumbling, blind, for oxygen: “I didn’t say that I agreed with the Alabama ruling. What the question that I was asked is, ‘Do I believe an embryo is a baby?’ I do think that if you look in the definition, an embryo is considered an unborn baby.” In the course of a single conversation, meanwhile, Alabama Sen. Tommy Tuberville said he was “all for” the ruling, then said the pause on IVF treatments in Alabama was “really hard” and that we “need more kids.” Then he diverted to “I’d have to look at the entire bill, how it’s written” (what bill?) and finally landed on: “This is a state issue.” Yeah, no kidding!
Other politicians who had a hard time responding to this news included Sen. Tim Scott, who dodged the issue with a simple “Well, I haven’t studied the issue,” despite the fact that he, like Tuberville, co-sponsored Rand Paul’s 2021 “personhood bill,” which would have likely banned IVF.
Republicans in the House also had a hard time responding to the matter thanks to their own “Life at Conception Act,” which has 124 co-sponsors and no carve-out for IVF. House Rep. Nancy Mace, one of the co-sponsors, pinned a tweet declaring that she would “stop any and all efforts to ban IVF.” (The tweet comes with a contextual note from readers that clarifies that she … is a co-sponsor of an act with no carve-out for IVF.) The Democratic opposition research machine is fully whirring as campaign season rolls around. When Michigan Senate candidate Mike Rogers stated that he opposes “any and all efforts to restrict access to IVF—period,” his rival, Elissa Slotkin, pointed to four bills he co-sponsored that threatened IVF.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementSome Republicans tried to go the more personal route. Reps. Michelle Steel and David Schweikert, both co-sponsors of the Life at Conception Act—which is still in committee and has not had a hearing—spoke of IVF helping their own families. “IVF allowed me, as it has so many others, to start my family,” Steel tweeted on Thursday. “My wife and I struggled for years to have children,” Schweikert wrote Friday. Both faced accusations of caring about reproductive freedom only as it affected them.
Related From Slate
Mark Joseph Stern
Alabama’s Assault on IVF Is Even Worse Than It Sounds
Read MoreOther Republicans attempted to frame IVF as a pro-life issue, sometimes awkwardly. Florida Rep. Byron Donalds, speaking on Meet the Presson Sunday, tried to imitate Donald Trump, who wrote on social media, “We want to make it easier for mothers and fathers to have babies, not harder!” But what he actually managed to say was that IVF is important to couples because “it helps them breed great families.” Who doesn’t want to “breed” a great family? “Our country needs that,” he added.
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- The Lawyer Defending Idaho’s Abortion Ban Irritated the One Justice He Needed on His Side
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- You Don’t Want to Know How It’s Going Between Trump’s Lawyers and the Judge Presiding Over His Criminal Case
- Prosecutors Are Finally Revealing Their Strategy Against Trump
The Republican party knows this is bad—to the point where the Senate Republicans’ campaign group sent a memo to its candidates on Friday instructing them to “align with the public’s overwhelming support for I.V.F. and fertility treatments.” As the memo noted, 85 percent of all respondents in the group’s polling support increased access to fertility treatments, and even 83 percent of evangelical Christians support IVF. Candidates were instructed in the memo to support IVF without equivocation and to reject “any efforts” to restrict access. It’s no wonder that Republicans, including House Speaker Mike Johnson, went out of their way in their messaging to avoid being tagged the anti-IVF party.It would be a political death knell.
But Republicans saying that they absolutely adore IVF won’t get Democrats off their case just yet. Those who say they support—want to expand, even!—access to IVF procedures as well as broadly worded legislation determining that life begins at conception are in a contradictory position. All eyes will be on the Alabama Legislature, which has promised to take action to ensure the legality of IVF procedures, to see what sort of exception it carves out. Until the Republican Party can determine that path forward, their tongues will remain tied.
Tweet Share Share Comment-
PS5 Pro: There are new whispers that the release date is fast approachingUN rapporteur on North Korea human rights to visit South Korea this weekDonald Trump referred to Stormy Daniels as 'horseface.' Seriously.我市开启大熊猫溯源科考研学之旅How much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?收购价、零售价双升,潮州橄榄喜迎丰收年!正式启动“2018万人游芦山暨全域旅游”活动Jordan Peterson brings the “dark web” to Aspen.GPU Mining is Dead, Where are my Cheap GPUs?Sasnovich sets up Indian Wells clash with Raducanu
- ·微视频广东:在推进中国式现代化建设中走在前列
- ·Twitter #BeAVoter campaign experienced a brief but hilarious bug
- ·Moon says 36 million people to get vaccine shots by end of September
- ·名师“一对一”指导!30强全力备战半决赛丨2023广东乡村歌手大赛
- ·Black Friday GPU Buying Guide: November GPU Pricing Update
- ·交通事故致一人命悬一线 民生救援队员路遇相救脱险
- ·Moon says 36 million people to get vaccine shots by end of September
- ·法治润泽农旅茶旅融合发展“花”
- ·iPhone 16 Pro new color will reportedly be Desert Titanium
- ·The Google walkout in Los Angeles was private and restrained
- ·减肥有望 小鼠实验发现抗肥胖靶点
- ·Vice FM Choi holds talks with Iranian counterpart on frozen Tehran assets, JCPOA
- ·Microwave technique recovers 87% of batteries' lithium in 15 minutes
- ·There's a Twitter campaign to get Trump out of office using your spare change
- ·Google workers demand company stop selling tech to police
- ·Minor opposition party leader in self
- ·Amazon Android Days sale 2024: Save on unlocked phones, tablets, and more
- ·“薯”你重磅!云浮云城“番薯王”惊艳亮相广东种业大会
- ·正式启动“2018万人游芦山暨全域旅游”活动
- ·Marty the grocery store robot is a glimpse into our hell
- ·Sports minister says audits into football, badminton federations set to conclude in Sept.
- ·Disney commits to changing Splash Mountain's 'Song of the South' theme
- ·市中级人民法院建立扫黑除恶专项审判合议庭
- ·Story of a widow, a lake, and a rose will restore your faith in humanity
- ·Coach jailed for sexual exploitation of underage athlete
- ·Calls for delaying allied military drills gain traction inside ruling party
- ·Bernie Sanders’ DNC speech sounded like everyone else’s. That’s astonishing.
- ·Comcast lets parents automatically boot kids off WiFi after daily max
- ·North Korea to hold major legislature session this weekend after missile tests
- ·青山绿水间 游客享清凉
- ·Tesla reveals Cybertruck has sold more than DeLorean
- ·栽种方竹能致富 做足生态大文章
- ·There's a Twitter campaign to get Trump out of office using your spare change
- ·The Google walkout in Los Angeles was private and restrained
- ·Apple's iPhone 17 will come with a huge RAM upgrade, report claims
- ·People raised $36k for a Starbucks barista after he asked a 'Karen' to wear a mask