Potential breakthrough but long way to go
时间:2024-09-23 05:35:23 来源:玉林新闻
Analysts question whether NK buying time to complete ICBM
By Kim Jae-kyoung
The latest agreement between the two Koreas for an inter-Korean summit is paving the way to find a potential breakthrough in the North Korea nuclear crisis, experts said Thursday.
They, however, called on Seoul and Washington to remain prudent because the North's peace overture could be a calibrated strategy aimed at buying time to complete its nuclear-tipped long-range missile.
They expect that North Korean leader Kim Jong-un will demand a withdrawal of U.S. troops from South Korea in return for giving up its nuclear weapons.
"This is a positive development. What Kim Jong-un is requesting is what was provided in the Sept. 19, 2005, Joint Statement," Joseph DeTrani, a former U.S. special envoy to the six-party talks with North Korea, told The Korea Times.
From his perspective, the North's willingness to halt nuclear tests and missile launches should be sufficient to get the U.S. to the table to discuss denuclearization and the requested security assurances Kim wants.
However, DeTrani, currently a professor at Missouri State University's Graduate Department of Defense and Strategic Studies in Fairfax, Virginia (a suburb of Washington, D.C.), said the key is moving forward, knowing Kim wants a halt to joint military exercises and the lifting of sanctions.
"These are all negotiable for complete, verifiable and irreversible denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula," he said.
The view came after Cheong Wa Dae announced Tuesday that the two Koreas agreed to hold an inter-Korean summit at the truce village of Panmunjeom at the end of April.
Pyongyang also expressed its willingness to hold talks with Washington on denuclearization, saying it could give up its nuclear weapons if the safety of its regime was guaranteed.
William Brown, adjunct professor at Georgetown School of Foreign Service, said that these are very welcome developments on several fronts.
"The summit is to be on neutral ground, in Panmunjom, not Pyongyang. North Korea is apparently willing to discuss denuclearization, and the upcoming exercises are said not to interfere with the process," he said.
"Pyongyang may have a somewhat different spin but there is potential here for a real breakthrough."
Sean King, senior vice president of Park Strategies, echoed the view, saying that it's worth noting that next month's inter-Korean summit will be on the south side of Panmunjom.
"As such, this means the summit won't be the usual tributary pilgrimage north as in 2000 and 2007," he said.
"This is a symbolic climb down for Kim Jong-un and should at least give Moon Jae-in some perceived leverage."
Regarding the possibility of Pyongyang giving up nuclear weapons, the analysts said that it is going to be a long and difficult negotiating process.
Brown, who previously worked for the CIA and the National Intelligence Council, believes that guaranteeing safety, in North Korea's mind, might mean the withdrawal of U.S. Forces from Korea.
"I don't think the U.S. can guarantee the safety of the regime, say from internal disruption," he said.
"But we can, and should, guarantee that we would not initiate an attack on a North Korea that does not have nuclear weapons, and that we would never use nuclear weapons against a non-nuclear state."
Will NK give up nukes?
King, a New York-based East Asia specialist, stressed that South Korea and the U.S. should not forget the North traditionally defines the safety of its regime as the withdrawal of U.S. troops from the Korean peninsula and an end to the U.S.-South Korean mutual defense treaty.
This, he believes, will expose the South to northern coercion and/or a second North Korean invasion.
"That means we'd be right back to where we were before the Korean War, again leaving the South vulnerable," he said.
He pointed out that the North's nukes would have in effect already served their purpose without ever having been used and the South could be there for the taking.
Tara O, adjunct fellow at the Pacific Forum CSIS, doubts that North Korea is serious about giving up its nuclear weapons.
She noted that the North talked about a nuclear freeze in the past and that there were agreements to do so but it did not follow through.
"North Korea continued to develop nuclear weapons even while the talks were going on," she said.
"With the U.S. having all options on the table, North Korea is afraid of potential strikes. North Korea wants to buy time until it completes a nuclear-tipped ICBM, which can strike the U.S."
The analysts expect that U.S. President Donald Trump will eventually respond positively to a peace overture from the recalcitrant North Korean leader.
"Trump's always indicated a willingness to engage the North directly and the latest news gives him the diplomatic and political cover to do so," King said.
"I just hope we don't give away anything meaningful when talking. For example, sanctions must stay."
By Kim Jae-kyoung
The latest agreement between the two Koreas for an inter-Korean summit is paving the way to find a potential breakthrough in the North Korea nuclear crisis, experts said Thursday.
They, however, called on Seoul and Washington to remain prudent because the North's peace overture could be a calibrated strategy aimed at buying time to complete its nuclear-tipped long-range missile.
They expect that North Korean leader Kim Jong-un will demand a withdrawal of U.S. troops from South Korea in return for giving up its nuclear weapons.
"This is a positive development. What Kim Jong-un is requesting is what was provided in the Sept. 19, 2005, Joint Statement," Joseph DeTrani, a former U.S. special envoy to the six-party talks with North Korea, told The Korea Times.
From his perspective, the North's willingness to halt nuclear tests and missile launches should be sufficient to get the U.S. to the table to discuss denuclearization and the requested security assurances Kim wants.
However, DeTrani, currently a professor at Missouri State University's Graduate Department of Defense and Strategic Studies in Fairfax, Virginia (a suburb of Washington, D.C.), said the key is moving forward, knowing Kim wants a halt to joint military exercises and the lifting of sanctions.
"These are all negotiable for complete, verifiable and irreversible denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula," he said.
The view came after Cheong Wa Dae announced Tuesday that the two Koreas agreed to hold an inter-Korean summit at the truce village of Panmunjeom at the end of April.
Pyongyang also expressed its willingness to hold talks with Washington on denuclearization, saying it could give up its nuclear weapons if the safety of its regime was guaranteed.
William Brown, adjunct professor at Georgetown School of Foreign Service, said that these are very welcome developments on several fronts.
"The summit is to be on neutral ground, in Panmunjom, not Pyongyang. North Korea is apparently willing to discuss denuclearization, and the upcoming exercises are said not to interfere with the process," he said.
"Pyongyang may have a somewhat different spin but there is potential here for a real breakthrough."
Sean King, senior vice president of Park Strategies, echoed the view, saying that it's worth noting that next month's inter-Korean summit will be on the south side of Panmunjom.
"As such, this means the summit won't be the usual tributary pilgrimage north as in 2000 and 2007," he said.
"This is a symbolic climb down for Kim Jong-un and should at least give Moon Jae-in some perceived leverage."
Regarding the possibility of Pyongyang giving up nuclear weapons, the analysts said that it is going to be a long and difficult negotiating process.
Brown, who previously worked for the CIA and the National Intelligence Council, believes that guaranteeing safety, in North Korea's mind, might mean the withdrawal of U.S. Forces from Korea.
"I don't think the U.S. can guarantee the safety of the regime, say from internal disruption," he said.
"But we can, and should, guarantee that we would not initiate an attack on a North Korea that does not have nuclear weapons, and that we would never use nuclear weapons against a non-nuclear state."
Will NK give up nukes?
King, a New York-based East Asia specialist, stressed that South Korea and the U.S. should not forget the North traditionally defines the safety of its regime as the withdrawal of U.S. troops from the Korean peninsula and an end to the U.S.-South Korean mutual defense treaty.
This, he believes, will expose the South to northern coercion and/or a second North Korean invasion.
"That means we'd be right back to where we were before the Korean War, again leaving the South vulnerable," he said.
He pointed out that the North's nukes would have in effect already served their purpose without ever having been used and the South could be there for the taking.
Tara O, adjunct fellow at the Pacific Forum CSIS, doubts that North Korea is serious about giving up its nuclear weapons.
She noted that the North talked about a nuclear freeze in the past and that there were agreements to do so but it did not follow through.
"North Korea continued to develop nuclear weapons even while the talks were going on," she said.
"With the U.S. having all options on the table, North Korea is afraid of potential strikes. North Korea wants to buy time until it completes a nuclear-tipped ICBM, which can strike the U.S."
The analysts expect that U.S. President Donald Trump will eventually respond positively to a peace overture from the recalcitrant North Korean leader.
"Trump's always indicated a willingness to engage the North directly and the latest news gives him the diplomatic and political cover to do so," King said.
"I just hope we don't give away anything meaningful when talking. For example, sanctions must stay."
-
Deceased K高州沙田镇早熟储良龙眼上市,收购价13元/斤Three jjimjilbang reject teens after Gangneung accidentCavani desire to leave PSG sparks Lampard interest21 Lost and Lonely Cemeteries心存侥幸骗保被识破 秉公执法办案得赞誉Rashford sixSandra Bland: Is the bail system that kept her in prison unconstitutional?水产品占“四席”!广州南沙十个农产品上榜“国字号”Meta's new AI tools will get you shopping even more on Instagram
上一篇:Who is the Dark Wizard in 'The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power' Season 2?
下一篇:Slot extends perfect Liverpool start
下一篇:Slot extends perfect Liverpool start
相关内容
- ·12 Sculptures Made From Recycled Materials
- ·Former Supreme Court chief summoned as suspect over power abuse scandal
- ·Korea hits back with its own video clip over radar spat
- ·North Korean foreign minister in high demand at UN
- ·South Korea beefs up drills amid escalating NK provocations
- ·Former Supreme Court chief summoned as suspect over power abuse scandal
- ·PM calls for efforts to build future
- ·Snapchat adds augmented reality Easter egg hunt to Snap Maps
- ·The Astounding World of Automata
- ·Ruling party lawmaker under fire for alleged real
- ·做好排查 保障汛期林业安全
- ·Expectations high for North Korea
- ·iPhone 16 Pro new color will reportedly be Desert Titanium
- ·Donald Trump congratulated Roseanne Barr for the 'Roseanne' ratings
- ·This toy advert is taking on gender stereotypes and people love it
- ·Microsoft Copilot: Free tier gets AI upgrade to GPT
最新内容
- ·Spate of defections show Kim Jong
- ·Saxby Chambliss wants Edward Snowden hanged on the courthouse square.
- ·People are loving Hillary Clinton's burns on Donald Trump
- ·Liverpool's long title wait a warning for Manchester United
- ·Game Plan
- ·Malfunctioning sprinkler suspected as cause of hotel fire in Cheonan
- ·以学促干!江门市“三支一扶”人员红色加速营培训班开班
- ·Hillary Clinton turned her website into a fact checker for the debate
- ·A Journey Into the Mind of Stephen King
- ·People are gluing tiny flowers to their faces for this new eyebrow trend
推荐内容
热点内容
- ·Keurig K Mini deal — get $30 off at Target
- ·每年可宰2900万头猪!秦英林成中国最大杀猪匠!
- ·Rashford six
- ·市政协三届28次主席会议召开
- ·The Astounding World of Automata
- ·Former Supreme Court chief summoned as suspect over power abuse scandal
- ·FM does not rule out surprise announcement on 2nd US
- ·Pompeo to travel to Pyongyang on Oct. 7, meet Kim
- ·New Grok response directs users to Vote.gov for election questions
- ·'Sad Bernie' sends the internet into a meme