Trump trials: Jack Smith is reportedly reconsidering his strategy.
Donald Trump has been convicted of 34 felony counts in the New York hush money case—but there’s a lengthy appeals process ahead. And what ever happened to the other three cases against him—Jack Smith’s federal election interference and classified documents cases, and Fani Willis’ Georgia election interference case? All three have hit various roadblocks. To make it easier to follow all of Trump’s ongoing legal entanglements, each Monday, we’ll keep you updated on the latest developments in Keeping Up With the Trump Trials.
Special counsel Jack Smith is taking a long, hard look at his election interference case—and a New York Times report says Smith has decided against asking for a comprehensive review of evidence and witness testimony in a high-stakes hearing scheduled for next week. Meanwhile, New York Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan is considering whether to delay Donald Trump’s sentencing for a second time in the hush money case or let it continue as planned, despite Trump’s defense team appealing the case on the grounds of presidential immunity. And after a nearly six-week-long wait, on Monday Smith finally filed his appeal of Judge Alieen Cannon’s decision to dismiss his classified documents case.
The Special Counsel Is Revising His Strategy in the Jan. 6 Case
Two weeks ago, Jack Smith requested an extension of an Aug. 9 filing deadline so he could have more time to figure out his next move in his election interference case. Now the special counsel is also against holding a hearing that would decide which of Trump’s charges should stick after the Supreme Court ruled Trump—and all future U.S. presidents—has a level of presidential immunity for actions taken while in the White House.
This prospective hearing could have turned into a mini-trial, where witnesses and experts get called to testify and make the case for why Trump’s charges should remain or should be dropped. It’s an exercise judges in all of Trump’s ongoing criminal cases will have to go through in order to apply the Supreme Court’s presidential immunity decision. And unnamed sources told the New York Times that Smith is now against holding a mini-trial in his own election interference case, as it would inevitably lead to a highly publicized airing of critical evidence mere weeks before the presidential election. Trump’s defense team would most likely object to this type of hearing, claiming it’s unfair to his ongoing presidential campaign.
AdvertisementMeanwhile, anonymous sources familiar with Smith’s decisionmaking also told Bloomberg that his team is revising their case against Trump. Both Trump and Smith have to formally detail their preferences for how Judge Tanya Chutkan should consider the federal election interference charges in light of the Supreme Court’s ruling by Aug. 30—an extension that Chutkan agreed to after a separate request by Smith. A hearing is scheduled for Sept. 5.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementIf Smith decides not to recommend any witness testimony or debate over evidence, it would be a big win for the former president. From the onset of Smith’s case, Trump has railed against the special counsel and his investigation, claiming political persecution. If Trump wins the November election, he’s expected to direct his Department of Justice to drop Smith’s case—but if Vice President Kamala Harris wins, the special counsel’s case will have a new lease on life.
So Will Trump Be Sentenced Next Month, or What?
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg told Justice Merchan that he’s not opposed to delaying Trump’s sentencing, currently scheduled for Sept. 18, which Trump has asked to push back pending his presidential immunity appeal. And now the decision lies in Merchan’s hands, with the presidential election a mere 10 weeks away.
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- Kamala Harris May Finally Be the Opponent That Makes Donald Trump Fully Lose It
- So Is Donald Trump Jr. Cursed, or What?
- A Global Problem Is Preventing the Wars in Ukraine and Gaza From Coming to an End
- The Trump and Harris Campaigns Are Pivoting to a New Skirmish
“Ordinarily, if the defendant asks for a delay, and the prosecutor doesn’t object, then it would absolutely be granted,” Adam Pollock, former assistant attorney general of New York, told Slate in an email. However, most judges want to resolve cases quickly, allowing all parties involved to get some closure, and Pollock believes there is a not-insignificant chance that Merchan will stick to Sept. 18 and simply proceed with sentencing Trump.
AdvertisementIf Merchan does not further delay sentencing—he already did once after the Supreme Court’s presidential immunity decision was released in June—Trump’s immunity appeal could still upend it, especially if the appeal is successful. Given that, Pollock noted that delaying Trump’s sentencing until after his appeal is resolved could save the justice some effort.
AdvertisementAnother factor to consider is whether Merchan will sentence Trump to prison. Pollock believes that’s unlikely, given this is a nonviolent crime and Trump is a first-time offender. However, if Merchan keeps the Sept. 18 sentencing and does not give Trump prison time, it could be used as fodder in his appeal to suggest the hush money case was nothing but political theater. But if Merchan decides to give Trump prison time on Sept. 18, it could tangibly impact the November election.
AdvertisementMerchan has said he’ll announce his decision to either delay or keep Trump’s current sentencing date on Sept. 16.
Related From Slate
Shirin Ali
The Trump Hush Money Trial Judge Is Getting Pretty Tired of This
Read MoreSmith Officially Appeals the Decision to Dismiss the Classified Documents Case
New court filings made public on Monday revealed that the special counsel has officially filed an appeal against Judge Aileen Cannon’s decision to dismiss his classified documents case, nearly six weeks after filing a notice of appeal.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementIn July, Cannon dismissed the classified documents case, arguing that Smith was improperly appointed as special counsel by Attorney General Merrick Garland, and therefore he can’t legally prosecute Trump. On Monday, Smith pushed back on that assertion, writing that Cannon “misconstrued the statutes that authorized the Special Counsel’s appointment, and took inadequate account of the longstanding history of Attorney General’s appointments of special counsels.”
Smith points to the Watergate scandal, which also used a special counsel to investigate Republican president Richard Nixon back in 1973. That appointment came after the Supreme Court ruled in United States v. Nixonthat the AG did have statutory authority to assign special counsels. Smith argues Cannon is the only judge who has ever challenged the high court’s decision.
Advertisement“The Supreme Court regularly uses qualifying language to indicate assumed premises but included no such caveat in Nixonwhen discussing the Attorney General’s authority to appoint the Special Prosecutor,” Smith wrote. “Nixontherefore binds this Court, just as it did the district court, and reversal is warranted on that ground alone.”
Smith filed his appeal with the 11thCircuit Court of Appeals, which has already laid out a schedule for the appeals process in this case. Both Smith and Trump are required to file briefs through mid-October, and oral arguments will likely be held a few months after that. The timeline suggests that Smith’s appeal of Cannon’s decision to dismiss will stretch well beyond November’s presidential election. And if Trump wins, his DOJ will almost certainly drop this case.
Tweet Share Share Comment-
Prime exclusive deal: $50 off Govee floor lampMike Bloomberg is out. But he's still memeModular building facade heats and cools rooms with solar powerThai Embassy to promote esports on Thailand Game DayExpanded police surveillance will get us “broken windows” on steroids.'No Time To Die' release delayed until November due to coronavirusPersuading US to ease sanctions 'top priority' for implementing interNorth Korean WMD pose threat to neighbors, violate UN Security Council resolutions: US official17 Spectacular Outdoor StaircasesPersuading US to ease sanctions 'top priority' for implementing inter
- ·24 Museums Dedicated to Black History
- ·结合政协工作实际开展“大学习、大讨论、大调研”活动
- ·清远连山举办丝苗米机插育秧及高产栽培技术培训活动
- ·AT&T's 5G
- ·提前谋划部署准备秋季开学
- ·Injecting this sensor under your skin could prevent future pandemics
- ·清远连山举办丝苗米机插育秧及高产栽培技术培训活动
- ·Chinese tokamak keeps plasma 2.6 times as hot as the Sun for 17 minutes
- ·[From the Scene] How ‘world’s first oil town’ is wrestling to become ‘green'
- ·掌上智慧医院 让就医更轻松
- ·Twitter makes it easier to appeal decisions about bad behavior
- ·Race organizers and athletes turn to simulators amid coronavirus
- ·Best Labor Day headphones deals: Apple, Bose, Beats, and more on sale
- ·Church puts their nativity scene in a cage to protest Trump's immigration policies
- ·Netflix's 'On My Block' Season 3 finale: Why the show should end now
- ·结合政协工作实际开展“大学习、大讨论、大调研”活动
- ·US Open 2024 livestream: How to watch US Open tennis for free
- ·'Animal Crossing: New Horizons' review: The best cure for stress
- ·美加宝马建升:“差不多思维”让养猪业落后!再省不要省育种
- ·Bailey, Elizabeth Warren's very good dog, stole and ate a burrito
- ·World's first green ammonia plant is now open for business
- ·Reminder: Airbnb lets hosts put cameras inside your rental
- ·Twitter vows to make itself less spammy with new policy change
- ·You can play 'Snake' in the Google Maps app
- ·24 of the Oldest Trees in the World
- ·Carrie Gracie donates backdated BBC pay to help other women fighting for equality
- ·Where to pre
- ·North Korea says it will sever diplomatic relations with Malaysia for extraditing citizen to US
- ·Precious newborn cheetah cubs will stare deep into your jaded soul
- ·Reminder: Airbnb lets hosts put cameras inside your rental
- ·Elon Musk's AI facility is reportedly operating gas turbines without a permit
- ·Microsoft gains control of domains used by Iranian hackers linked to U.S. fugitive
- ·开展护理创新 推动学科发展
- ·Tessa Thompson says she's attracted to men and women. Happy pride!
- ·Deceased K
- ·筛选品种擦亮品牌!省农科院水稻所助力清远丝苗米发展