Debunking a Myth: DDR3 RAM vs. ECC Memory Performance
Recently, a workstation PC was reviewed on a well-known PC hardware site that included a Quadro video card, but no ECC memory. In the comment section of that review, a heated discussion occurred with different readers arguing about whether the lack of ECC RAM was a good or bad thing in a workstation. One side argued that ECC is great for workstations since it is much more stable (as explained in this Advantages of ECC Memory article) and stability is very high priority for a workstation. The other side claimed that ECC memory was slower than non-ECC so it wasn't the right choice for a high-end workstation where performance was a priority.
Much of the ECC versus Non-ECC argument comes down to speed versus reliability. The reliability argument at least is easy to validate; over the last 12 months we've seen a tiny .09% failure rate with ECC memory compared to a .6% failure rate for standard memory. As for performance, we've actually tested RAM performance in the past and found that faster memory does not always equate to better performance since the RAM is often not the bottleneck.
Editor's Note:This guest article by Matt Bach was originally published on the Puget blog. Matt has been with Puget since the early days working in the various subsets of production and is currently the head of Puget Labs.
However, the expected performance drop of ECC RAM is slightly different than what we saw in those tests since it's due to the extra error checking process rather than slower timings or frequency. In fact, Crucial has a statement on their knowledge base that ECC memory will decrease your computer's performance by about 2% compared to standard memory.
Alas, to settle the question of whether ECC actually lowers system performance we ran a series of benchmarks with standard RAM, ECC RAM, and Registered ECC RAM that all run at the exact same frequency, timings, and voltage.
Test Setup
To examine the performance of the three kinds of memory, we used the following hardware:
-
How much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?Why do NK defectors flee to destitute North?The internet mocks Alex Jones' conspiracy theory with #SecondCivilWarLetters龙年·龙舟·龙眼|抬头见喜,有龙则灵South Korea beefs up drills amid escalating NK provocationsInstagram is testing offline functionalityNK leader discusses 'war deterrent' at Central Military Commission meetingTrump excessively touting success with NK for reelection13 Unbelievable Underwater Wonders in FloridaUS, South Korea form 'better foundation' for declaration of end to Korean War: Seoul envoy
- ·提前谋划部署准备秋季开学
- ·North Korean parade on Saturday could unveil new missiles: unification ministry
- ·Volcanoes, ranked: The world's best volcanoes
- ·North Korean leader pledges full support for China in letter to Xi: KCNA
- ·From Prairie Grasslands to Man
- ·华南农业大学南方大豆创新研究院成立
- ·The 'on brand' childhood memories meme is taking over Twitter
- ·England fan gets soccer player's face tattooed on his chest after making Twitter promise
- ·NASA rover snaps photo of its most daunting challenge yet
- ·雪厚凌重 雅西高速石棉段新年首次封闭道路11小时
- ·Despite Iran and climate deals, the the Doomsday Clock is still at three minutes to midnight.
- ·Fortnite mystery: Durr Burger appears in California desert
- ·'Black Myth: Wukong' PS5 review in progress: A potential masterpiece
- ·US extends travel ban on North Korea for third time, citing 'serious risk'
- ·Gal Gadot dressed like Wonder Woman to visit real
- ·Bernie Sanders new ad is optimistic and diverse.
- ·World's first 18650
- ·North Korea marks 'victory' anniversary
- ·雷岭荔枝:送给“顶天荔地”的他
- ·Oregon wildlife refuge occupation continues after arrest, death.
- ·[Exclusive] Samsung unsure of Suga's future as brand ambassador: source
- ·Polar fitness app revealed sensitive information of overseas soldiers
- ·Gal Gadot dressed like Wonder Woman to visit real
- ·Apocalyptic video, photos show dust storm engulf Arizona desert
- ·Pope says England are not 'one
- ·Man faces arrest for stabbing wife, daughter to death
- ·提前谋划部署准备秋季开学
- ·North Korea to defy coronavirus with huge parade
- ·Woman rescues her attacked pup with a tip she learned on Reddit
- ·Prosecution chief nominee vows political neautrality
- ·13 Astronomical Clocks Connecting Time And Space
- ·灾后重建项目落户 雨城区首批重楼长势好
- ·Oregon wildlife refuge occupation continues after arrest, death.
- ·Cats on Instagram wish you a meowy Christmas and a happy mew year
- ·Families of S. Korean detainees in NK appeal to embassies for support
- ·'She's not waking up:' Boy saves mom using Siri to call ambulance