Mark Zuckerberg's former mentor says privacy manifesto is a PR stunt
One of Mark Zuckerberg's earliest allies in Silicon Valley says the Facebook CEO's recent privacy manifesto is little more than a PR stunt that won't solve the company's most serious problems.
Speaking at SXSW, Roger McNamee, an early Facebook investor and and onetime advisor to Zuckerberg, called the CEO's recent promise to rebuild Facebook as a "privacy-focused" platform "a very effective public relations move that once again is deflecting us away from the core problem."
McNamee, who once counseled Zuckerberg not to sell Facebook to Yahoo, and to hire Sheryl Sandberg as COO, has become a vocal critic of the social network in recent years. (He's currently promoting his book, Zucked: Waking Up to the Facebook Catastrophe, in which he says Zuckerberg and Sandberg ignored his warnings about Russian activity on Facebook in 2016.)
SEE ALSO:Why we should all be skeptical of Mark Zuckerberg's new commitment to privacyNow, McNamee says Zuckerberg's supposed commitment to encryption and privacy is much more self-interested than he has let on.
"I'm a big believer in end-to-end encryption, but I think we all need to understand that encrypting your messages, and encrypting your posts addresses about one 1 percent of the problem," he said.
"It has a convenient byproduct, which makes me think there must be something bad coming, maybe it's the FTC... maybe it's something else. But they're doing something that they would do anyway. If you end-to-end encrypt, your moderation problem goes away. So from Facebook's point of view, what they're trying to do is get credit for something like it's noble but doesn't address the problem."
The biggest problem, according to McNamee, is that Facebook's business model relies on tracking an enormous amount of data about what its users do when they aren't even on Facebook.
At the end of he day, the thing that really worries me, and this so-called manifesto doesn't touch that, is that the value, and the problems, really are associated with metadata and data collecting outside of Facebook, neither of which are covered by this manifesto.
Zuck made very clear... that they're not getting out of the tracking business. My problem with Facebook is not whether it's end-to end-encrypted... it's what are they doing with the tracking, what are they doing to invade my private spaces. I don't want then buying my credit card history, I do not want them doing business with health and wellness apps, I do not want them buying my location data from my cellular carrier, I do not want them tracking me all around the web.
McNamee also expressed support for Elizabeth Warren's plan to break up big tech companies like Facebook, Google, and Apple. His appearance at SXSW comes just one day after Warren took the stage in Austin to discuss her plan for dismantling large tech companies she says are making it more difficult for smaller companies to innovate.
The Facebook investor, who noted that he still holds stock in the company, did have some positive words for the social network. He said if Zuckerberg follows though on his promise to not have data centers in authoritarian countries it would be a "righteous" move, and that he doesn't think Zuckerberg or Sandberg should step away from Facebook.
"I don't think this is about the people, and I believe that this is about the business model. Mark and Sheryl at Facebook have the moral authority to change the business model. They can do 100 times as much good by reforming their companies than they could possibly do with a foundation."
Featured Video For You
Feel like your phone's spying on you? You're not alone
-
尝“鲜”盛宴,等你来探!2024年清远西牛麻竹笋尝鲜季即将启幕荔枝+音乐,超赞!茂南乡村歌手唱响“爱的古荔”Russian FM to visit Pyongyang next month as followUS stresses opposition to any arms provision to Hamas amid claimed use of N. Korean weapons多措并举优治理 绘就幸福新图景Fun Disney content is on its way to NetflixArsenal agree deal to sign Brighton defender White: reportJames Franco has a YouTube channel about philosophy because of course he does9 Festive Holiday Treats and Where to Find ThemBest TV deals this week: LG's 2024 C4 OLEDs, cheap QLEDs
- ·CrowdStrike outage is still causing hundreds of flight cancellations daily
- ·Comedian's ultra
- ·iPhone owners sue Apple over 'Touch Disease'
- ·Kickstarter opens in Asia, starting in Hong Kong and Singapore
- ·Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage
- ·Best TV deals this week: LG's 2024 C4 OLEDs, cheap QLEDs
- ·N. Korea's SLBM test conducted from barge, not from submarine: U.S. expert
- ·Here are Trump and Scaramucci's scenes from that Wall Street movie
- ·Campbell highlights Washington Declaration amid security concerns over Putin
- ·Comedian's ultra
- ·Poland celebrates rise as Central European powerhouse
- ·US expert redoubles calls for sturdier deterrence against NK ICBM threats
- ·Foreign, multicultural students rise amid declining school population
- ·N. Korea's SLBM test conducted from barge, not from submarine: U.S. expert
- ·S. Korea, Japan to reopen finance ministers' talks on weekend
- ·Tesla recalls 1.8 million cars over hood issue
- ·Apple Watch bands: 5 favorites to consider as Apple Watch 10 looms
- ·Here are Trump and Scaramucci's scenes from that Wall Street movie
- ·[Herald Interview] Educating girls ‘way to end poverty’
- ·Best headphones deal: The Sonos Ace are on sale for the first time ever.
- ·21 College and University Museums
- ·Poland celebrates rise as Central European powerhouse
- ·Get up to 33% off OLED TVs during Samsung OLED week
- ·New York governor in hot water over shark photos
- ·'Hyundai Way': Auto giant's W121tr plan aims to seize mobility market lead
- ·Kickstarter opens in Asia, starting in Hong Kong and Singapore
- ·夏凤俭与四川建安工业有限责任公司董事长耿海波座谈
- ·14省生猪存栏同比大降,山东最高跌16.7%!猪价要涨的节奏?
- ·Gen Z might be the hardest workers yet
- ·南粤福和山茶油:“东方橄榄油”,健康与美味的绿色密码
- ·US Open 2024 livestream: How to watch US Open tennis for free
- ·N. Korea's SLBM test conducted from barge, not from submarine: U.S. expert
- ·The internet descends upon this super hot selfie of the Queen's former page boy
- ·N. Korean threats impede Asian growth: Park
- ·World's first green ammonia plant is now open for business
- ·Tesla recalls 1.8 million cars over hood issue